http://sierraclub.typepad.com/compass/2009/11/another-coal-plant-bites-the-dust.html
This week’s post
was co-written by Mary Anne Hitt, deputy director of the Sierra Club Beyond
Coal Campaign
We’re celebrating great news out of Minnesota
and South Dakota this week:
“After almost five years of planning and permitting efforts, the participating
utilities in the proposed Big Stone II Project announced…Monday that they will
end their quest to build the project’s large coal-fired power plant and
associated transmission facilities.”
We echo our own Cesia Kearns, a
Sierra Club staffer from Minnesota, in what the halting of Big Stone II means for the region.
“The failure of this enormous proposed coal plant expansion unravels the myth
that the Midwest is starving for more electricity, and that coal is the
only way to adequately meet that perceived need,” Kearns said. “This victory demonstrates that
even when we may lose the battles - consistent pressure, engaged citizens, and
strong partnerships can win the war.
It's a strong example of how even though the regulators may be on the
side of a developer, the public is not.”
We salute our tough band of local residents in South
Dakota and Minnesota
(the plant was proposed for northeastern South Dakota,
near the border with Minnesota),
who spent the last five years fighting this dirty coal plant. The Sierra Club also partnered with grassroots, state, and
regional organizations during this long and difficult campaign. They
knew how bad the air pollution and global warming contributions this plant
would spew forth would be, they wanted clean energy for their region, and even
when the going got tough, they never gave up.
Stopping the Big Stone II project
prevented about 4.7 million tons of CO2, or the equivalent of the pollution
from roughly 670,000 cars (substantially more than all the cars in South Dakota) from entering the atmosphere every year.
The residents so entrenched in this fight against Big Stone
II helped lead a long fight against the Minnesota
Public Utilities Commission for its issuance of an air pollution permit for the
plant and, equally importantly, an enforcement action targeting the existing coal-fired
unit at the Big Stone facility for past violations of the Clean Air Act. We also challenged the state of South Dakota's Clean Air Act plan for failure to comply with federal
law.
Kearns added that one noteworthy example of the grassroots push
for clean energy was the mention of Sierra Club's "footprint
petition" in the Administrative Law Judge's written recommendation to the
MN Public Utilities Commission to deny the certificate of need for Big Stone
II’s transmission lines.
“The footprint petition was a long
swath of fabric with the signatures and outlines of the footprints of over
2,000 Minnesotans who wanted to see global warming solutions in Minnesota,” explained Kearns. “It was presented to the Administrative Law Judge during
a public hearing in Ortonville, Minnesota - the town closest to the location of the proposed plant.”
This plant’s demise is also a sign
of impending climate legislation. Otter Tail Power had pulled out of this plant
back in September, citing, among other reasons,
“a high level of uncertainty associated with
proposed federal climate legislation and existing federal environmental
regulation.”
No other utilities stepped in to take
over the Big Stone II expansion themselves – because the companies all know
that this legislation is coming.
Coal power is not the future of U.S. energy. The public is
speaking up for more clean energy. And from coast to coast, that voice is
getting louder every day.